Winnie the Pooh New Year and Mickey’s Christmas Carol

Written by George Taylor. Posted in Disney, Disney Movies, Features, The Disney Review

Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Published on November 10, 2013 at 1:00 am with 4 Comments

George: It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas…and Disney wants you to help fill their stockings! Disney has just released two holiday-related blu-rays to get you in the mood. Or to get you to empty your wallets on new releases of some items you might already own. The first one up is Winnie the Pooh: A Very Merry Pooh Year. This is the first time I’ve seen this and it will be the last. Actually, I started looking at Instagram on my phone and missed most of it.

Jeff: I remember seeing the film back in 2002, when it was originally released. It suffers like most direct to video sequels: terrible storyline, even worse songs, and forgettable overall. I was honestly kind of surprised that this was a film they were releasing for the holiday season, being as that it doesn’t have that big of a following. And like George said, if you watch it, you can see why.


George: The quality of the Pooh-ray (get it?) does suffer. They did digitally enhance it, but it’s the same format release from 2002. It’s not widescreen which is very odd to watch on a modern television. Honestly, there was nothing redeeming about this release and the only reasons to pick it up are if you’re a huge Pooh fan and you don’t own it or you collect everything Pooh-related.

Jeff: Adding even more fuel to the fire, there is a considerable lack of extras on the disc. Sure, you can watch and sing along to the handful of songs from the film (with the lyrics on or off), but they are forgettable and honestly not all that great. It really seems like no effort went into this release, and it shows, from the lack of digital restoration to the lackluster package overall.

George: Nothing else to see here…moving along. So, the next release is the 30th Anniversary of Mickey’s Christmas Carol. This 1983 animated short film is considered a classic by most Disney fans. I do love it and it’s part of our annual holiday watching. I do own it on several other DVDs and I have to admit that I was glad to receive a review copy on blu-ray. The familiar retelling of the Dickens’ tale was the first theatrical release of an animated Mickey film in over 30 years. It wasn’t until I finished watching the short film, that I realized I had a blu-ray with about 45 minutes worth of content on it, including the minimal special features.

Jeff: Normally, because I do love the movie so much, I wouldn’t mind how short the blu-ray’s entire running time is. However, being touted as a digitally remastered, 30th Anniversary edition, I have to say I’m pretty unimpressed with it overall. The film itself looks terrible; it’s almost as if someone took the “smear” tool in Photoshop and ran it over every frame of the film. It’s a lazy “restoration” (if you can even call it that) and it’s one for the worst. If you compare the film on the disc itself to the actual menu on the blu-ray, you’ll notice a VAST difference in quality. It’s sad when the menu for the film looks much better than the film itself.


George: I agree that the film didn’t standout like other blu-ray conversions (Little Mermaid, My Neighbor Totoro) and seemed rather disappointing. I’m hard-pressed to recommend this title simply because the quality just doesn’t seem to be there. As I’ve mentioned, I already own this film on three other DVDs and the quality on the previous copies is far superior. Still, the film, itself, is a classic. The shorts included on the disc are entertaining and are more winter inspired than holiday. Is it worth getting this, though?

Jeff: Many of the shorts, including the new one Yodelburg, are available, for free, online in some way (whether on Disney’s site or on YouTube). So, like George, I’m hard pressed to recommend this title as well. If you really want to own the film, and don’t already, you’re better off buying one of the older editions on DVD. Or, just watch it on TV, as I’m sure it will be on many, many times between now and Christmas.

George: Man, we sound like Scrooge McDuck before his three ghostly visitors.

Jeff: Bah humbug!

So, what do you think about these two releases?

By Jeff Heimbuch and George Taylor

The Disney Review is written and edited by Jeff Heimbuch and George Taylor

If you have any questions or comments, feel free to email us at
[email protected] or [email protected]

You can follow us on Twitter @imaginerding (George) and @JeffHeimbuch

Other places you can find George and Jeff:

You can also see us EVERY week on Communicore Weekly on the MiceChat Youtube Channel.

About George Taylor

George has been obsessed with Disney theme parks since the first time he saw a photo of the Haunted Mansion in the early 70s. He started writing about Disney in 2007 and has amassed one of the world's largest Disney-related libraries.

Browse Archived Articles by


Comments for Winnie the Pooh New Year and Mickey’s Christmas Carol are now closed.

  1. It’s truly tragic that Disney have let so many bad releases out recently including the faulty Little Mermaid discs, it makes me wonder if they have someone new in charge of Disney video distribution that is no more than a bean counter and really doesn’t care at all. I wanted to buy the blu ray of Mickey’s Christmas Carol but I’ll stick with my older copies and hope sometime in the future they will pick up their game.

  2. If this new blu-ray version of Mickey’s Christmas Carolis so disappointing, can you tell me which is the better version to buy between the original DVD of this film and the 30th Anniversary Edition? Thanks!

    • Buy the original DVD. The 30th Anniversary edition DVD that just came out along with this Blu-Ray features the same transfer, so it’s not worth the price.

      • Thanks for the head’s up!