See, that's where I disagree re: tearing the book apart. I could tell that ShockerBatman wasn't engaged and didn't feel included. Dividing up the books would give each person ownership of their section. Yes, it's a mess. It's ALWAYS going to be a mess. Giving ShockerBatman the entire book later is overwhelming for him as it would be for me and Jeff too.
Eventually... the book DID fall apart and having Jeff scour his pages for Paradise PIer questions while I scour my section for the same really helped I thought.
Four people isn't too much if everyone is king of their own questions. I also think maybe saving the transferring of all answers for the last 5-10 minutes would have been good.
Just my opinion and will continue to be until I try that next year and fail. haha