Phantom Manor vs. The Haunted Mansion

[Frank_The_Tank]

which version of the ride is better

which has better theme..
which one more scary...

[geoffa]

Hard to say. The storylines are totally different. I like the new stuff atWDW - the footsteps under the stairs, the disappearing husbands' heads in the portraits and the bride with the axe. At Paris I like the Manor - it's a whole lot creepier on the exterior - almost Psycho!

[Zarniwoop]

Phantom Manor is scariest. Visit the graveyard late evening... and I promise goosebumps on your neck before you find Ravenswoods final resting place.

[nathan detroit]

Phantom Manor was better. Now its in need of some major TLC.

The story in PM is better although I miss the hitch-hiking ghosts and the shivering caretaker and his dog.

[TDR_Fan]

It's hard to say which is better, as they are both excellent attractions. Depending on your preference and taste, either one could be viewed as the better version.

[Grizzly]

I loved Phantom Manor a lot better. It was such a different take on it.

[Malin]

15 years a go if you had asked this question I think most of us would of gone with Phantom Manor. Now thanks to the lack of maintenance its a differnt story.