View Poll Results: Which version would you prefer if Disney's Mine Ride still existed?

Voters
48. You may not vote on this poll
  • Knotts Berry Farms Mine Ride

    19 39.58%
  • Disneyland's Mine Train's to Natures Wonderland

    32 66.67%
Multiple Choice Poll.
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 28
  1. #1

    • Future Indy Castmember
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Torrance, California, United States
    Posts
    5,535

    Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    We all know that Disneyland's Mine Train to Natures Wonderland was something worth going to back in the 50's and 60's and is not there anymore, with it being replaced by Big Thunder.

    In some ways though, I think the Mine Trains were in some ways, revived. No I'm not talking about it returning to Disneyland. I'm talking about Knotts Berry Farms Mine Train Ride which is still opened today.

    While Disney's version focused on Natures Wonderland, Knotts version focuses on going through Calico's Mines.

    So heres the question that you can answer with the poll attached as well. If Disneyland's Mine Train ride was still opened, whih version would you prefer? Knotts or Disney's?

    And do you think that Knotts Berry Farms Mine Ride is a spiritual version of Disney's?



    Duffeteer Society of Tenders, Artists & Romantics
    Check out the
    MICECHAT Duffy Forum
    Bringing the Love since January 10, 2011



    The world is a treasure trove of places.
    The colors of Earth, Sea and Sky. Beauty i'm told, is ours to behold. In the wonderful world of color.
    Indy Ride Count: 2211
    World of Color Count: 74

  2. #2

    • Dapper Dan-nabe
    • Offline

    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    North Hollywood, CA
    Posts
    387

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Just from a quality standpoint I have to assume that MTTNW would be superior to the Calico Mine Train. I've been to Knott's once and was seriously unimpressed with the Calico train. The sound system was so lousy I couldn't hear a word the conductor was saying, the trains were uncomfortable and very slow to load (longest line I waited in all day), and the human figures in the ride (I can't in good conscience refer to them as AAs) were roughly "traveling carnival" quality. Some of the scenery was nice (the large, central, multi-level mining operation comes to mind), but on the whole I felt like the ride was a dark, slow, meandering mess without much in the way of a cohesive story experience. I left feeling like it was a prime example of why Disney has been so much more successful than Knott's (other than, you know, built in global brand recognition).
    -SilentDante
    eliselzer.blogspot.com

  3. #3

    • Senior Minion
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    8,890

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Sorry, but having ridden both many times, comparing Knott's mine train to Disneyland's is like comparing a state baseball team to a national. They all have bats, balls and gloves, but there the similarity ends.


    "With the acquisition of Marvel and now of Lucasfilm,
    Disney may have finally found the grail. You don't need
    imagination or art. All you need is a brand."

    - Neil Gabler


  4. #4

    • Beach Expert
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    A beach town that Harbor Blvd was named after
    Posts
    10,635

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    I think too many people are quick to criticize Knott's. And much of that is deserved, especially since Cedar Fair took over.

    But the Calico Mine Train is really a great ride, and one that not only is Disney-caliber in terms of themeing but one that also had a lot of influence on Walt Disney himself.

    The Calico Mine Train was built in 1960. It was built after Disney's Mine Train but before POTC. And it had more influence on Walt Disney than a lot of Disney fans would want to admit. It was the first major theme park ride to incorporate part of the queue within the attraction itself. I also mentioned POTC because in my opinion it was a major influence on that ride. Especially in the grotto where the rockwork of the cave is not only beside you but above you. Before POTC most of Disney's rides had plain ceilings like in the FL dark rides or on iasw.

    Sure. The AA technology in the Knott's version is pretty crude. But it is an immersive experience, and one that Walt tried to copy and succeeded with his masterpiece, POTC.

  5. #5

    • Senior Minion
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    8,890

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Quote Originally Posted by DisneyIPresume View Post
    The AA technology in the Knott's version is pretty crude. But it is an immersive experience, and one that Walt tried to copy and succeeded with his masterpiece, POTC.
    I'm not criticizing Knott's or their Mine Train, both of which I'm fond of -- but I find it difficult to believe that Walt or WED "tried to copy" anything from Knotts for Pirates of the Caribbean (especially when you consider the development history of POTC).


    "With the acquisition of Marvel and now of Lucasfilm,
    Disney may have finally found the grail. You don't need
    imagination or art. All you need is a brand."

    - Neil Gabler


  6. #6

    • Thinking about doughnuts
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    San Diego
    Posts
    502

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Knott's mine train is more of a dark ride with limited outdoor parts. It does have one large interesting room in it and does have some nice little tunnel sections. That main room is interesting to watch even if the animatronics (closer to mannequins) aren't that great.

    But Disneyland's mine train went past Rivers of America, some beautiful waterfalls, bears, goofy looking cactus, geysers, and ended with those indoor blacklight waters. It was mostly an outdoor train which was like riding through one of their nature films. To modern park goers it might not sound like much but it was one of my favorite rides at the park as a kid. The thrills were non-existant but the interesting things to see in its little journey made it a classic ride.

    Knott's mine train is a dark ride worth going on but a different kind of ride and not in the same league as the large, expansive, and mostly outdoor Disneyland mine train.

  7. #7

    • Autobot Weapon Specialist
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Santa Ana, CA
    Posts
    6,208

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr Wiggins View Post
    I'm not criticizing Knott's or their Mine Train, both of which I'm fond of -- but I find it difficult to believe that Walt or WED "tried to copy" anything from Knotts for Pirates of the Caribbean (especially when you consider the development history of POTC).


    1969:

    1989:

    Just sayin.




  8. #8

    • Animatronic
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    1,860

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    While there's no doubt that Disneyland and Knotts had some healthy competition for a few years, Disney's Mine Train Ride through Nature's Wonderland was rather epic. Picture Thunder Mountain and Jungle Cruise combined in both size and length. There's just no way the reduced scope of Knott's Mine ride could compete.

    That said, I'm glad at least one of the two mine train rides survived.
    it's a sale of candy and a sale of plush, it's a sale of toys and disney stuff
    there's so much that we sell, that it's time we tell, it's a plush plush sale!

  9. #9

    • Shag lover
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Phoenix, AZ
    Posts
    164

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Quote Originally Posted by SilentDante View Post
    ...the human figures in the ride...were roughly "traveling carnival" quality.
    The creepy undead miners?













    *BRAINS!!!!!!!*
    Coming on a whirlwind trip 12/4 and 12/5 just to see the holiday decorations. Hope the park isn't too full of spoiled mall-goers to enjoy!

  10. #10

    • Closed Account
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    5,897

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    I've been lucky enough to have ridden both.

    Only one still captivates the young logger in me.

    They're different ride; one a flume and one a train. That makes comparisons nearly impossible.

  11. #11

    • Senior Minion
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    8,890

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Quote Originally Posted by Mr Wiggins View Post
    ...I find it difficult to believe that Walt or WED "tried to copy" anything from Knotts for Pirates of the Caribbean (especially when you consider the development history of POTC).
    Quote Originally Posted by k_peek_2000 View Post
    1969:

    1989:

    Just sayin.
    I said "Walt or WED," not "He Who Calls Finding Nemo Submarine Voyage a 'Major E-Ticket' and WDI."


    Last edited by Mr Wiggins; 08-17-2009 at 05:58 PM.
    "With the acquisition of Marvel and now of Lucasfilm,
    Disney may have finally found the grail. You don't need
    imagination or art. All you need is a brand."

    - Neil Gabler


  12. #12

    • =)
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    13,290

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    I'm confused...are we talking about the Calico Mine Train, or the Timber Mountain Log Ride?


  13. #13

    • Not-So-New Member
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Carson, CA
    Posts
    223

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Mine train.
    -Chris

  14. #14

    • Member
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Too Far From Disney
    Posts
    3,497

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    It's kind of hard to criticize because Walt based his off of Knotts. It's said that Walt Knotts and Walt Disney were good friends and Walt Disney got some of his inspirations from Knotts.
    DisneyTwins
    Since May 2003

  15. #15

    • Member
    • Offline

    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Long Beach, CA
    Posts
    470

    Re: Knotts Mine Train ride compared to Disney's

    Quote Originally Posted by Disneytwins View Post
    It's kind of hard to criticize because Walt based his off of Knotts. It's said that Walt Knotts and Walt Disney were good friends and Walt Disney got some of his inspirations from Knotts.

    They were friendly and Walt did get some inspiration from Knotts Berry Farm. Walt observed crowd movements at KBF to figure out how he wanted Disneyland to be layed out. It made sense, Knotts was already there, it was only 5 miles away so the visitors and the weather would be comparable.

    They also both knew that the other wasn't competition at all. Disney brought quite a few people to Southern California to visit his park. People generally don't take a family vacation in a station wagon across country and visit only one place.

    Walt Disney and Walter Knott actually didn't compete, they complimented each other. When people go to Orlando I'm guessing that The Magic Kingdom isn't their only destination. Why do you think Sea World and Universal both built parks there?

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Mine Train - when did it close..
    By tofubeast in forum Yesterland
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 11-24-2009, 12:24 PM
  2. [Question] Old Mine train tracks
    By passholder in forum Disneyland Resort
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 07-09-2009, 12:32 PM
  3. [Fun] Lego Mine Train
    By hbwriter in forum Disneyland Resort
    Replies: 24
    Last Post: 09-14-2008, 05:29 PM
  4. Should the Mine Train be removed.
    By Walt Jr. in forum Disneyland Resort
    Replies: 29
    Last Post: 08-02-2007, 03:20 PM
  5. Mine Train AP pin - May 14
    By cstephens in forum Disneyland Resort
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 04-22-2006, 04:33 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •