The prop in the ToT queue that stands out in my mind is the phone from the episode where the kid talks to his dead grandmother on said phone and she tries to get him to kill himself because she's lonely. My dad loved that episode. He'd always repeat the line "Grandma... is that you?"
I need to get more pics. I think RoseRedAngel used to have a whole list of the props which is why she yoinked all my DVD-R's with all the Twilight Zone incarnations on them and watched them without me