I've never been on Rockin' Space Mountain or Rockin' California Screamin', nor will I ever have the chance, so this is from an outsider who only knows what she reads.
I think the majority of you, the Disney fans, and the public agree that the Rockin' promotions haven't exactly gone over well. While most of the complaints I've seen about the new overlays for Space Mountain and California Screamin' focus on the poor show elements and overall weak idea, there have been the few "The Red Hot Chili Peppers? The guys who have performed with only socks covering their privates?" comments thrown out.
A change in band may not necessarily improve the rides, but do you think the promotion would have been at least received better had a more Disney-friendly band been chosen?
All the Rockin' flaws aside, if the choice of band and music came down on your shoulders, who/what would you choose?