I have a real problem with the Ghost of Christmas Past
They tried to make the character silly but that is not the character. Isn't the character supposed to be forcing Scrooge to reflect on the past and thus should be in the sort of mood as well? I think Muppet Christmas Carol actually did a better job on the ghosts than this movie. They really captured the spirit of that past present and future are without going to extremes. Past was silly, present was too creepy and future was not creepy enough...
Overall it was an OK movie. I enjoyed it but I don't think I am going to go out of my way to watch it again. We did the 3-d and yes it was visually beautiful, but like I said, over all I am sort of ho hum about the whole thing.
I really think Michale Cain's Scrooge was what Scrooge is, so watching Jim Carey make a mockery of the character was difficult for me. (And I LOVE Jim Carey!)
5/10 for me, not horrendous but not stupendous.