Re: Hoop De Doo or Polynesian Luau, which one to see?
I enjoyed them both and couldn't decide on just one. The only thing I can say is the Luau is partially exposed to the weather so depending on when you go Florida's rain storms may effect your plans. The one time I went to the Luau, (in June) our show was delayed from a passing storm, and the wait staff needed time to dry off the seats. But you said you were going in December so the storms aren't as likely but something to consider.
Which ever one you don't get to do will just have to be on your list next time you visit