Sorry, but wrong!
I think you completely miss the fact that comic book movies, like Star Trek movies, Harry Potter movies, Twilight movies, Silence of the Lambs, etc. - any movies based on a material that's already successful in another medium and thus garnered a population of fans - will need to carefully balance pleasing existing fans as well as draw fans who have not already read or seen the source material in order to make the studios wallets very happy. And some properties like Harry Potter and Batman lean towards dark themes in their original material.
Now, specific to films based on comic books, I say as reader of a varied range of comic book material in the over 30 years of my 40-something years of life, you cannot definitively state comic books are "
always made to be books ment to please everyone not just adults". As evidence, I present the films
Road to Perdition,
V for Vendetta,
From Hell,
Ghost World, and
A History of Violence, all well received films that many non-comic book reading audiences likely didn't know were based on comic books or their adult-sounding
nom de plumb, graphic novels.
I do agree with you that "dark does not equal good" as an absolute rule. But as an old fart who doesn't always like his super-heroes being messed with, I do recognize Hollywood's POV that going "dark" or "edgy" is a consideration they need to consider in order to cater to broader audiences.
Back OT, I voted 4. Richard Donner and Christopher Reeve gave us what needed to happen, a 100% copy from comic page to movie screen realization of the Superman suit. It was The Film that taught Hollywood and movie audiences that it was okay to play comic book characters straight and not dumbed down only for little ones. And that suit ranks as 5. The latest version by Zack Snyder and Henry Cavill is one I've sort of lived with for a year now. I saw the first still when it was released a year ago, and then DC Comics restarted their entire line of comic books, resulting in Superman also getting a costume makeover. And guess what? The new and current suit in the comic books no longer has red trunks either!
I've been reading Superman comic books for a year now, so whatever shock issues I had with the new suit design in the books I've gotten over. And the same goes with the movie version of the suit.
Bookmarks