My opinion on the intended topic follows. Typos and confusion first:
On to the real topic: These sort of arguments get kicked around all the time (Aladdin in DCA is the current whipping boy). While the Indy Stunt show is getting old for the repeat visitor, I think it's still good fun. I'd also agree that, despite the current Jack-Sparrow-Mania, a live Pirates show would be too much, considering the dark ride just down the road on which it would be based. I'm in favor of keeping Indy.
1) The abbreviated title of this thread on the index page says, "It is time to close Indiana".
This recently happened to New Jersey, so it's not that far-fetched.
2) The proposed replacement show sounds quite painful: "Pirates of the Caribbean Stun
spectacular!". Ouch!! (Cattle prods, I presume.)