I chose Fantasmic, but I hardly see it since I hate waiting for a seat. I also don't like to spend that much time away from the rides. I enjoyed VOTLM in all its full show glory, with the Sebastian puppet. Now its been gutted so much I am disappointed when I watch it.
In what way has the show been gutted? I just saw it a couple weeks ago, and almost everything was there and working, to my recollection. The cool rising lasers that made it seem like you were descending underwater haven't been doing their rising motion for years. But other than that I thought all was working very well.
And I agree with others - the Hunchback show was head & shoulders above all the rest!